Gareth Reynolds [Interview]

Happy 4th of July weekend Everyone! It’s that time of year we take a moment to look back on just how awesome it truly is to be an American. Because if you are like some of us, you probably spend the rest of the year being shamefully reminded of some of the truly fucked up shit we have done. Especially if you are a fan of the brilliant man we are going to showcase today!

Late last year, I had a great interview go live with a man I admired for his work on one of my favorite television shows in recent history called Maron. His name was Dave Anthony. He was a funny guy, and gave a wonderful interview. And in that interview, he happened to mention that he has an American history podcast entitled The Dollop. I had not heard of The Dollop for some dumbass reason, so I decided I would check it out. And wouldn’t you know it, I began proverbially kicking myself in my own ass for having checked out this beautiful godddamned podcast prior to interviewing Dave. It has since become my hands down favorite piece of media available right now. And I have vowed to get revenge on myself for making such a stupid, stupid, stupid mistake. It was a torturous winter that led into a hellish spring….but now summer is here. And vengeance shall be mine…..

Today we have a wonderful interview with Gareth Reynolds…..Comedian. Writer. Actor. Producer. Buzz Lightyear Impersonator. Flappers Cat Wrangler. And most importantly…Podcaster. Yes, Gareth, or Gary as some would incorrectly call him, is the amazing other half of the duo that makes The Dollop so incredible. For those of you who are not familiar with The Dollop, the premise is simple, yet crazily perplex. The aforementioned Dave Anthony tells a story to Gareth from American (mostly) history, the kicker being that Gareth has no idea what the topic is going to be about. And that is almost specifically what makes this podcast so damn amazing. Gareth’s reactions to some of the most fucked up events in American history is absolutely priceless and pure gold.

And through The Dollop, I have actually become a huge fan of Gareth’s entire body of work. He is a brilliant stand-up comedian and actor. He has appeared on numerous television shows, including Quick Draw with our old friends Bob Clendenin and Alexia Dox, and the previously mentioned Maron with Dave Anthony and another old friend Troy Ruptash. And while The Dollop may be the finest podcast I have ever heard, Gareth also happens to have another podcast that is almost equally amazing entitled Point Vs. Point, with former bar soap-rape victim Evan Mann, where Gareth takes a somewhat different approach than the Dollop playing the frantic and hyperactive character next to Evan’s straight man character. It is absolutely hilarious and another must listen.

So, why don’t we just get right into it, shall we? Ladies and Gentleman, co-host of two of the finest podcasts and one of the finest stand up comedians of our time, Mr. Gareth Reynolds!

When did you realize that you were a hilarious human being, and you owed it to the world to make them laugh whenever possible?

Well, I just realized right now when you told me that! Honestly, I guess when I was a kid I quickly found out I could make other kids laugh and that was fun. When I was 6 I did goldylocks and the three bears in French. A must see, I know. I don’t know what I was doing as the baby bear but I was adding looks and other things that got laughs. I knew it was either making people giggle or professional hockey. So around then. And then as I got older I found ways to use it to delay classes starting if I had teachers laughing. I was hooked! Laughter is addictive but making someone laugh is heroin. It’s my favorite.

I am always curious to know what stand up scenes are like in different, and maybe not so obvious, regions of the country. So, what was the stand up scene in Milwaukee like when you were first starting out? And when you occasionally go back around, has it changed much?


Well, I actually really started in New York for a half year or so and never really experienced the milwaukee scene stand up wise. Improv was what I did in Milwaukee and I loved it. I worked at a place called comedysportz and was around really really funny people all the time. I listened to them about what I should do after high school and generally sponged up their humor. Like in ‘Space Jam’ but with comedy in place of basketball. I’ve done stand up in the Midwest since and there are a ton of funny comics. I love doing shows in those parts.

What is your opinion of the current state of comedy? With all of the advancements in technology and so many different mediums, do you believe the quality of comedy has suffered? Or maybe that more people are getting the chance to show off their skills?

Well, like with the internet there are good and negative aspects. Someone who is talented can now get their voice out there so much easier than a decade ago. You used to have to move to LA or New York to get noticed but now you have people gaining followings and making money from all over the country and world. The downside is that a lot of it sucks and it clogs the market. Like vine stars. Sure, some were funny but for crafting comedy and making something valuable doesn’t seem like it can have an 8 second cap to it. God I sound old….and music is too loud!!

I will arguably say right here and now that The Dollop is the finest podcast out right now. After close to 3 years of regularly doing this show, what do you believe it is that keeps you interested and wanting to continue on talking about these crazy stories?

I appreciate it! Well, it still interests me I guess is the answer. History in school was never enticing to me, but the stories we cover on the dollop are so layered and crazy. I always think Dave will run out of tales but he has a deep bench. There are also so many parallels to our society today. We feel like we have come so far, and yet, we still have many many issues that have plagued us for years. It’s genuinely shifted my perspective on my day to day excitence. I can’t get enough.

Gareth Reynolds & Dave Anthony of The Dollop

The chemistry between you and Dave is undeniably one of the best elements of The Dollop. In your personal opinion, what do you believe it is that makes you guys work so well together?

I think because we are different honestly. Dave is teaching me and I am a class clown in his class. Sound familiar?(I am referencing an earlier answer, this is a ‘callback’) But I now have a cool teacher! We know going in that it will be fun. I don’t know what he is going to say and he doesn’t know what I will say, but he has a road map that I trust. Also we now have such a shorthand with what the other is saying or doing. I am not sitting there dying to make jokes necessarily but what he lays it out he leaves me no choice, dammit! We get along great and both like to laugh. So it just has kind of worked out well. Thank god because I used to dress up like superheroes at kid’s parties and that wasn’t going great.

Have you had any serious backlash from some of the more controversial topics you guys cover on The Dollop? Has someone like Lenny Dykstra, or somebody you talked about who happens to still be alive, contacted you in anger? Or any other sort of received backlash from the show?

There’s some, yeah. I mean whoever is the focus of the story will get hit and others take some shrapnel. There have been some people who get upset from time to time but also some who are happy they were involved. We did one on a guy who lost both of his arms on a farm and iced the torn off appendages himself before getting them reattached at the hospital. He was great. We did an episode on it and the guy reached out to us! He said he was “pissing” himself. That was awesome and surreal. I do feel like Lenny Dykstra may murder sometimes, sure. But who doesn’t?? He’s the Dykeman!!

If you were given the opportunity to portray any individual featured in any episode of The Dollop on screen, who would it be?

Oh wow. Probably the rube or the lobotomy doctor. Or rainbow man. All three are such lunatics in their own right. The rube needs to be a film. We are starting to think we may have to write the thing!! But if I got any of those parts I would be “pissing” (this is another one of my classic ‘callbacks’).

So what does the future hold for you? Any new projects or shows you would like to plug to our reader(s)?

I am writing on Arrested Development currently, so people should watch the new season on Netflix when it comes out. Or drops, as the vine stars say (third callback and also employing the rule of 3 here). I’ll be putting out a stand up album soon and have dates coming up! Join me! The dollop will be touring Australia in the fall. Oh and we have a dollop book called ‘The United States of Absudity’ that people should check out.

What was the last thing that made you smile?

I watched a video of a dog jumping on a guy’s back into a pool and riding him like a surfboard. The dog was so god damned happy about it. Hard to not crack a toothy grin at that!

R.I.P. Jose

About rontrembathiii
write. write. write.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: